http://photos.wingyounghuie.com/eat/e58670c0a
This photograph, taken by Wing Young Huie under the "Eat" section of his collection, is simplistic at first, clearly portraying a reflection of the room. The two lights, table, and portrait create a mirror-like and basic effect, while the two people at the table also mirror each other in hand movements. The obvious disruption to the reflection image is the black and white subjects of the photograph. Though they are both male, one is a middle-aged white man and one is a teenage black boy. The white male is eating a salad with white dressing, and the boy is eating a rice dish with what looks to be Tabasco sauce. This is an example of othering because of the contrast of normalcy between the two males: the mundane appetizer of salad with dressing and the strange mixture of Tabasco sauce and rice. This suggests that white people's eating habits are what is "normal" and catered to in the real world. The portrait is also noteworthy because it is of a black man looking disapprovingly at the white man. This could indicate the photographer's own disapproval with the concept of white superiority. Contrasting these negative views of the racial implications in this photograph is the fact that a white and black male are eating together in a house. It suggests an intimacy that does not occur anywhere besides a home, and the combination of man and teenager is also unique and adds to the progressive ideologies of the photograph.
The Handmaid's Tale and this photograph present othering in, overall, different ways. They both show both sides of the power spectrum (the extremely powerful males and the subordinate females and the while adult and black boy). The females in Handmaid's Tale are explicitly treated as inferior, but the photograph is much more implicit. The slightly tilted view of the photograph represents othering; illustrating the superiority white people believe they have over black people. In reality they are just two people, whether eating at a kitchen table or otherwise. The two sitting at the table in the same positions show this perspective, and this is never seen in Handmaid's Tale, for even Moira, the extremely independent, rebellious woman in the novel, falls to the power of the male. Othering is also countered in this photograph because of the mirroring quality, as well as the idea mentioned earlier of black and white male coexistence--living together and eating together. In Atwood's novel, the men and women live together, but the women are treated as "containers, it's only the insides of our bodies that are important" (Atwood 124). There is no coexistence, there is solely use of women. Though the stereotype of black and white men normally not being together is proven time and again, this picture shows the opposite, rejecting some othering aspects. In The Handmaid's Tale, othering is seen so much that it is clearly rejected by the author, and, like Huie, conveys to the audience a major issue that Atwood feels must be addressed.
Citation: Atwood, Margaret. The Handmaid's Tale. New York: Ballantine Books, 1985. Print.
|
|
|
|
Hey Olivia!
ReplyDeleteI really liked that you pointed out many aspects of the image that I hadn't noticed in the beginning. Some of the things that I didn't see at first (until I read your response) were the mirroring effects and the eating habits. I really agree that the eating habits in the photo show "othering" because salad dressing seems much more normal and well-liked than Tabasco sauce and rice. In restaurants you usually have a choice of salad rather than rice, too.
I also agree with how the women in the novel and the black boy in the photo are inferior and the men in the novel and the white man in the photo are superiority. With what you pointed out about the women being treated as "containers" and the eating habits help to suggest that. And I also agree with coexistence being seen in the image but not within The Handmaid's Tale.
Great job!
Okay, so you this is awesome! I would have never caught the mirroring effect and I thought it was awesome how you pulled in direct parallels with The Handmaid's Tale. One thing I'd love to see is more direct contrasts between the man and the teenager such as posture and clothing. I think you had an awesome first blog post and I am super excited to see what else you post!
ReplyDeleteOlivia-
ReplyDeleteGreat thoughts in this post!
I caution you with making assumptions, seen here with your observations about the "why" behind the food. Can you support them with facts or Huie's own reasoning behind his choices?
You did a wonderful job of treating all parts of the prompt equally, which provided for a thorough response.